I have been a beloved, unconditional, intense, intrigued fan since I first heard "Monkey Wrench" in April of 1997. Here are my rankings:
1 Wasting Light
2 There Is Nothing Left to Lose
3 Concrete and Gold
4 The Colour and the Shape
5 Echoes, Silence, Patience & Grace
6 St. Cecilia
7 In Your Honor
8 Foo Fighters
9 Sonic Highways
10 Medium Rare
11 Skin & Bones
12 Five Songs & A Cover
13 One By One
14 Songs From the Laundry Room
Comments
Some of these are probably interchangeable depending on my mood, the top 3 definitely can change very quickly... but they are always there at the top with ESP&G
1 There Is Nothing Left to Lose
2 The Colour and the Shape
3 Wasting Light
4 Echoes, Silence, Patience & Grace
5 In Your Honor
6 Concrete and Gold
7 One By One
8 Foo Fighters
9 St. Cecilia
10 Sonic Highways
11 Medium Rare
12 Songs From the Laundry Room
13 Skin & Bones
14 Five Songs & A Cover
Likewise, my list is not static. But generally it would look something like this:
1. Echoes, Silence, Patience & Grace
2. There Is Nothing Left to Lose
3. The Colour and the Shape
4. Wasting Light
5. In Your Honor
6. One By One
7. Concrete and Gold
8. Foo Fighters
9. Medium Rare
10. Skin & Bones
11. St. Cecilia
12. Sonic Highways
13. Songs From the Laundry Room
14. Five Songs & A Cover